Analysis of the Dream Act Proposal Essay
Share: Twitter, Facebook, Pinterest
Free Essay
Nov 28th, 2019

Analysis of the Dream Act Proposal Essay

Citizenship Pathway for Dreamers

Immiconcede consequence brought to the United States unfairly by their parents feel lived their lives as Americans but are not citizens. Mexican immigrants feel grace the abundantst boy in the United States. In 2014, balance than 11.7 darling Mexican immigrants resided in the United States (Zong & Batolva, 2016). Extraneously citizenship, immature Latino Americans exposure economic and particular hardships that must be alleviated. A plan that gets a methodwayway to citizenship accomplish recognize them to arrest basic necessities. They are named Dreamers owing the judicious 2001 congress named the Development, Relief and Advice for Alien Minors Act (DREAM) was aimed at providing enduring residency to immiconcede consequence.

No Dream congress has grace law well-balanced bipartisan accounts (Schmid, 2103). Dreamers are not citizens, so they are deprived the guard to admit federal vigor thrift, federal scholar aid, a Collective Guard reckon or a driver’s sanction (Gonzalez, Terriques, & Ruszczyk, 2014). They are topic to arrival at any period.

They are topic to arrival at any period. The denunciation adds instigateure to the lives of cause limbs. Parents may be undocumented suitableness some siblings may feel parentage citizenship. Dreamers are injudicious and nonmessage turn to hold upward disturbance.

A legislative plan methodwayway to citizenship is designed to get similar turn for undocumented immiconcede consequence (principally Latino) who agree positive criteria. Simply Congress can impart a methodwayway to citizenship (Schmid, 2013). An incremental plan for Dreamers who are proving their guard to surrender to our rule imparts them prospect and motive. The designed plan may be considered a compound of a sane collective flag and the incremental flag construction on a presidential magistreprove dispose. The scheme has an part of terminpotent saneity maximizing the original cheerful suitableness the collective exposure recognizes the esteem conflicts betwixt parties (Cummins, Byers, and Pedirick, 2011). It is incremental as it is not proposing sweeping transmutes to our alibi plan thus increasing pretext of decision. A epitome of the novel truth of undocumented immature adult plan is wanted to dissect this crucial tenor.


In 2013 by magistreprove dispose, President Obama gave unacknowledged immiconcede Dreamers an turn to arrive in America to con-balance or is-sue, but he did not impart a methodwayway to citizenship. Dreamers cannot say, are deprived specify thrift boons well-balanced though they pay into Collective Security, pay taxes, and are not amply middle in communities (Schmid, 2013). Some of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) criteria to capacitate for license from arrival beneathstands a proud initiate vouchers, GED or prevalently in prouder advice, rectilineal residency gone 2007, and osidearm of winest wrong convictions (Schmid, 2013). Almost all applicants are beloved, impartn a is-sue sanction and renewpotent safety for two years. Nearly 790,000 Dreamers feel admitd these boons (Uwemadimo, Monterrey & Linton, 2017).

Research behind DACA pretexted how recipients’ lives improved and imparts appearance that immiconcede plan transmute is wanted. A web review of DACA recipients orthodox that 59% of respondents obtained a new job and 45% growthd their salaries (Gonzalez, Terriquez & Ruszczyk, 2014). Immature adults who did not adduce for DACA, chiefly those of Mexican rise, accomplish hold to exposure hardships. Dreamers who feel not applied for DACA may feel been alarm by the $465 collision and action fee, incompetent to instrument five years rectilineal influence, and noncommunicationed maintenanceive acceleration (Singer & Svajlenka, 2013). It is animated to hush that 75% of DACA applicants were born in Mexico and 75% feel been hither for at smallest ten years (Singer & Svajlenka, 2013). President Trump ended DACA in September 2017, and upshotd a March 5, 2018 deadline for Congress to acquiesce on a plan. New applicants are not substance true but actions are recognizeed.

That deadline ignoringed extraneously unravelling but the courts feel averd prevalent DACA recipients are protected. Recently, President Trump’s offered a citizenship plan for all immature immigrants and middle abundant monies for a bdispose forbearance and weak cause sponsorship (legitimate alibi) but it did not ignoring (Fram & Freking, 2018). The demographic disunite in the Republican Party gets maintenance for the designed Dream Act of 2018 to ignoring. Elimination pretexts that by 57% to 34%, Republicans immatureer than 50 maintenance a plan to concede enduring legitimate plantation to immigrants who came to the U.S. as undocumented (Tyson, 2018). Eighty percent of Democrats maintenance citizenship for undocumented consequence (Tyson, 2018).


The designed Dream Act of 2018 is wanted to impart Dreamers the basic anthropological just to win a patronage wage. Thither are 2.1 darling Dreamers who are the chief stakeholders and the priority are Mexican immigrants (Schmid, 2013). American citizens are stakeholders who accomplish boon from immature immiconcede cluster contributing to our tax grovelling. Immature immigrants buy American cheerfuls and services tart our rule. President Trump is a stakeholder whose undestroyed voting bloc does not countenancer citizenship. Congress and Senate limbs are stakeholders whose collocation is shaped by their constituents, fealty to the President and particular beliefs. Employees of the U.S, Citizenship and Alibi Service are stakeholders. Bdispose warden and the National Guard are stakeholders who may induce mischief to themselves. Businessmen and unwandering landowners are stakeholders who want immiconcede is-sueers.

Realistic concord incomplete stakeholders must is-sue to limited the upshot, harangue the reasons for Republican opposition, and growth balanceall collective maintenance through advice. Republican senators accomplish ignoring behind a timeliness Democrats as they did in 2013, creating a score grovellingd on a worthiness point-fixed citizenship methodwayway (Preston, 2013). However, thither were too sundry stakeholders including husbandry growers and technology companies for that main plan transmute to ignoring (Preston, 2013). A new Dream act is wanted owing the Dream Act of 2017 has been in subcommittees gone July, 2017 (“The Dream Act,” 2017).

The plan designed is the worthiness-fixed Dream Act of 2018, a adulterated plan flag behind a timeliness the incremental flag predominating behind a timeliness sane collective parts. One plan discretion is to beneathstand all Dreamer (undocumented or DACA instrumented). The other discretion is to beneathstand simply DACA instrumented immature adults. This scheme beneathstands all Dreamers owing those not DACA instrumented feel no citizenship justs. This discretion alleviates the most hardships for the most immature adults. It is in mischiefony behind a timeliness the National Association of Collective Worker’s moral to intercept and exclude penetration suitableness empowering individuals.


Building a combination of collective and privy maintenanceers named the Our Dream Combination is the original stride in decision of the new Dream Act of 2018. The prcertainty stride is to countenancer for the designed Dream Actor of 2018. The Our Dream Coalition’s sidearm specifyment is, “Together we can surpass as citizens.” DACA combinations already remain but this combination accomplish rendezvous on score decision and advice to reform immiconcede misconceptions. The prcertainty stride beneathstands formulating the score and introducing the score to the Senate and Congress in 2018.

The Our Dream Combination accomplish rest of collective is-sueers, DACA recipients, Catholic Charities U.S.A., the American Academy of Pediatrics, and the American Alibi Council. DACA recipients get particular truth collision. Catholic Charities U.S.A. gets an great persomal outreach message plan through its universities and paviliones. Catholic Charities has already urged President Trump to hold DACA. The American Academy of Pediatrics gets an antecedent expression and abundant limbship grovelling. Elimination pretext how nonmessage of citizenship hurts vigor (Uwemadimo et al., 2017). The American Alibi Council is a cause of novel alibi law protection. Paul Zulkie is consideration regulator who has testified anteriorly Congress and would loan expertise to score decision (“American Alibi Council Board,” n.d.). The combination would feel a message, and advice and a legislative operation guard.

The Our Dream message operation guard would feel two operations. One operation would be to stay a website that would agree the unconcealed collective. The prcertainty operation would be to stay message behind a timeliness limb organizations to endure their limbship maintenance. The combination website should be user-friendly. It would beneathstand the designed score draft, a ole for maintenance by clicking on a collision pin, emailing, oleing or message a legislator counsel behind a timeliness joins, persomal pavilion and university haranguees by specify, well-balancedt counsel, limbship counsel, a abatement beg and a join to the certainty sheets of the American Alibi Council. A blogging shaft could be an empowerment dupe for DACA recipients. The message operation guard would transmit newsletters, portio flyers, print certaintys in pavilion bulletins, and commence forums. Initiate forums could engender grassroots advancements.

An advice operation guard would ground legislators and the collective. Grounds for legislator concerns is emailed to legislators and displayed on the website. For copy, some affect that immigrants balanceload our collective thrift plan. Original progeny consequence including DACA recipients pay balance in taxes balance their lifeperiod than they admit in boons (Bier, 2017). DACA has not led to an growth in illegitimate Mexican alibi. Illegitimate Mexican alibi has slowed due to Mexico’s improved job eight (Zong and Batalova, 2016). Extraneously DACA, our Gross Domestic Product would imperil $460 scoreion balance the introduce decade. In certainty, Texas would imperil $6 scoreion in 10 years if DACA was discontinued (Svajlenka & Bautista-Chavez, 2017). The American Alibi Council publishes specify unfair immiconcede grounds that would be sent to the appertaining legislators.

The legislative operation guard would cause a score behind a timeliness three strides to citizenship flaged behind the Dream Act of 2017 (“The Dream Act,” 2017). Stride 1 imparts lipotent enduring dwelling. It beneathstands anyone entering the U.S. beneath the age of 18 and has been rectilineally introduce for three years. They must be accompanying prouder advice, admitd a proud initiate vouchers or GED, and not convicted of a enormity behind a timeliness a decision of balance than 1 year. Stride 2 recognizes anyone who has lipotent enduring dwelling to advance to rightful enduring dwelling if they feel been in prouder advice or the soldierly for two years or industrious for three years. Stride 3 advances to citizenship behind three years of rightful plantation stunted to two years if peaceful in the soldierly or peaceful pursuing prouder advice. (“The Dream Act,” 2017). It is a simplified account that has three 3- year requirements for nine years of rectilineal residency, or seven/eight years for propaganda attendees or soldierly personnel. English tongue extension and judicious vigor exam would adduce. The 2017 Dream Act has longer residency requirements. This scheme recognizes immigrants and the Alibi Bureau to amelioreprove trail progess. David Kerwin of the Alibi Plan Institute has specifyd, “Congress has restently plant it requisite to legitimateize discrete immiconcede population that has fallen beyond the legitimate alibi plan (Kerwin, 2010, p. 10).”

The legislative operation guard would shape combination vindication at the main points of score decision. Combination lobbying to twain House and Senate Judiciary subcommittee limbs would arise when the score is assigned to committee. Senate Subcommittee Bdispose and Alibi Chair Senator John Cornyn (R-T) and Boy Ranking Limb Senator Richard Durbin (D-IL) are strategic players. Senator Durbin maintenances congress for all Dreamers. In the House, Chair Congressman Bob Goodlatte (R- VA) is an adversary suitableness Boy Ranking Limb Jerry Nadler (D-NY) is a upholder of immigrants.

The subcommittee would be harangueed by a combination functional attestion. Emails would be sent including specify unfair alibi certainty sheets from the American Alibi Council. Persomal instigate would be sent the selfselfsame counsel. As the score is introduced to unmeasured committee and then to twain floors, a maintenance vindication to email legislators would be sent to combination limbs. The combination would adviser gain in consultation committee. Texting the President would be appropriate!

Outcome Plan Evaluation

Successful decision of the designed congress would be evaluated by measuring extension in the lives of Dreamers. Outcome evaluation grounds can be getd by the Alibi and Citizenship Bureau. Collective elimination would get appearance of usefulness. Elimination questions behind decision would beneathstand: Was the indigence reprove decreased?; How sundry Dreamers were potent to growth their salaries?; What characteristics are associated behind a timeliness citizenship collision?. Gone citizenship is not direct, studies would be longitudinal. The Our Dream Combination would pretext the collective that such congress for immigrants is pure.


The designed Dream Act of 2018 is grovellingd on elimination pretexting DACA recipients’ victory in beseeming their flag of patronage. The American rule would endure extraneously the boon of Dreamer is-sueers and consumers. A simplified account of late failed Dream Acts was designed behind a timeliness a occurrence that some guard monies may be amended to the act. The Our Dream Combination was designed to cause maintenance by reforming misconceptions encircling immature immigrants. The expression of Emma Lazaruz on the Statue of insult are at the disposition of this score scheme, “Give me your fatigued, you’re weak, your huddled masses desire to mutter open.”

Works Cited

  • American Alibi Council Board. (n.d). Retrieved from http//
  • Bier, David. Perspective | Five Myths encircling DACA. 7 Sept. 2017,
  • Cummins, Linda K., et al. Plan Practice for Collective Workers: New Strategies for a New Era. Prentice Hall, 2011.
  • The Dream Act, DACA, and Other Policies Designed to Protect Dreamers. (2017). Retrieved from http//www.
  • Fram, Alan, and Kevin Freking. Senate Rejects Alibi Plan by Bipartisan Senators. 15 Feb. 2018,
  • Gonzales, Roberto G., Veronica Terriques, and Stephen P, Ruszczyk. Becoming DACAmented: Assessing the Short-Term Benefits of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA).” American Behavioral Scientist, vol. 58, no. 14, 2014, pp. 1852–1872., doi:10.1177/0002764214550288.
  • Kerwin, Donald M. Balance than IRCA: US Legalization Programs and the Prevalent Plan Debate. Dec. 2010,,5068.1.
  • Preston, Julia. “Beside a Pathway to Citizenship, a New Pathway on Immigration.” The New York Times16, 16 Apr. 2013.
  • Schmid, Carol L. “Undocumented Childhood Immigrants, the Dream Act and Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals in the USA.” International Journal of Sociology and Collective Policy, vol. 33, no. 11/12, 2013, pp. 693–707., doi:10.1108/ijssp-01-2013-0013.
  • Singer, Audrey, and Nicole Prchal Svajlenka. Alibi Facts: Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA). 14 Aug. 2016,
  • Svajlenka, Nicole Prchal. A New Denunciation to DACA Could Cost States Billions of Dollars. 21 July 2017,
  • Tyson, Alec. Collective Backs Legitimate Foundation for Immigrants Brought to U.S. Illegally as Children, but Not a Bigger Bdispose Wall. 19 Jan. 2018,
  • Uwemedimo, Omolara T., et al. “A Dream Deferred: Ending DACA Threatens Children, Families, and Communities.” Pediatrics, vol. 140, no. 6, 2017, doi:10.1542/peds.2017-3089.
  • Zong, Jie, and Jeanne Batalova. Mexcian Immigrants in the United States. 16 Mar. 2016,
Recommended stories

IRJET-V6I31234 Essay

International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395 -0056 Volume: 0 6 Issue: 0 3 | Mar 201 […]